- Samuel Goergen - Logan
- Christie McNab - Heather Kelso
- Rolando Madigral - Gerry DeJesus
- Andrés Erickson - Avery
- Kate Dailey - Kimberly Cook
- Rultz Raymond - Detective Swayze's Partner
- JoAnn Willette - Debbie Puglisi
- Hope Jordan - Carrie Cauldill
- Nicole Paris Williams - Barbara Nunn
- Kamille McCuin - Cherry Lee Jones
- Marlon Perrier - Nelson Jones
- Skyler Adams - Jimmy Mickel
- Eli T. Peña - Chip Hojan
- Autumn Dial - Tammie Craycraft
- Kyle Findley - Cody Simmons
- Langley Cornwell - Connie Craycraft
- Julia Vasi - Jodi Sanderholm
- Courtney Dietz - Lori Virden
- Vanessa French - Cindy Sanderholm
- Jack Vincenty - Owen
- Burke Brown - Justin Thurber
- Aly Ward Azevedo - Anna Wood
- Pamela Gold - Jeanne Smith
- David Christian Welborn - Mike Iseman
- Braxton Bjerken - Nick Robinson
- Jeremy Thomas - Scott Wells
- Joe Morelli - Detective Bob Anton
- Nir Guzinski - Bar Patron
- Todd Sheeler - Detective Gerald Swayze
- Sarafina King - Martha Brailsford / Muriel (twin sister)
- Jason MacDonald - Tom Maimoni
- Ashlee Heath - Patti Maimoni
- Levi Burdick - Brian Brailsford
- Jesse Malinowski - Hooper Goodwin
- Marty Stonerock - Laurie Cabot (Salem Psychic)
- Allen O'Reilly - Harbor Master
- Whit Davies - Captain Finn
- Brianna Ferris - Sandy Jeffers
- Andrew Bellamy - Aaron Skeen
- Brody Wellmaker - James Anderson
- Lake Roberts - MD Det. Hendley
- Jennifer Baskette-Ridings - Angelia Jeffers
- Suehyla El-Attar - Sandy's Neighbor
- Angela Ray - Librarian
- Marilyn Chung - Student
- Kalyn Wood - Cassie Jo Stoddart
- Cory Chapman - Tory Adamcik
- Tyler Webster - Brian Draper
- Andrew Sweeney - Det. John Ganske
- Parisa Johnston - Officer Bozek
- Denise Arribas - Anna Stoddart
- Suzanne Salhaney - Aunt Allison
- Kristina Arjona - Cousin Kelsey
- Briana Starks - Ticket Taker
- Todd Brown - Tommy Ray
- Katherine Ramsland - Self - Forensic Psychologist
Capítulo disponible en las siguientes plataformas:
