- Keith Morrison - Narrator (voice)
- Michael Carollo - Officer Divozzo
- Mike Harkins - O'Fallon Office Dave
- Barry Clifton - Jerry
- Randall D. Cunningham - Polygrapher
- Gralen Bryant Banks - Plastic Surgeon
- Ricky Catter - Gus
- Chad Governale - Courtroom Bailiff
- David Kors - Juror #3
- Dickson Obahor - Sean Walker
- William McGovern - Jim
- Morgan Roberts - Evan
- Ron Centanni - Russ' Family Member
- Didi Costine - Teenage Witch
- Jesse Scott Egan - Detective Merkel
- Anthony Michael Frederick - Firefighter
- Kyler Porche - Randy Gunderson
- Emily Topper - Young Pam Hupp
- Lara Grice - Cousin Mary
- Cindy Pol - Whitney
- Lorna Street Dopson - Zumba Instructor
- Kenny Alfonso - Bob Rivers
- Jackson Kelly - Big Shot Manager
- Cuyle Carvin - Btian Hilke
- Bill Martin Williams - Judge Ted House
- Suzette Lange - Prisoner
- Kurt McKinney - Judge Cunningham
- Jessie Terrebonne - O'Fallon County Operator
- Jay Pennington - Bradford Kessler
- Rob Steinberg - Michael J. Kruse
- John C. Klein - Bailiff
- Terese Aiello - 911 Operator
- Jordan V. Allen - CSI Tech
- Ann Mahoney - Tammy
- Jeff Robins - Juror #2
- Anne Speed - Bar Patron (uncredited)
- Adam David Thompson - Captain Mike Lang
- Billy Slaughter - Scott
- Alec Zais - Young Mark Hupp
- Catherine Carlen - Bonnie
- Lena Clark - Lisa
- Celia Weston - Shirley Neumann
- Douglas M. Griffin - Judge Ohmer
- Madeline Colombo - Bubbly Acolyte
- Ian Hoch - Cybercrimes Expert
- Sarah Stipe - Sarah Hupp
- Sarah Stipe - Sarah Hupp (uncredited)
- Susan Shalhoub Larkin - Luci
- Samantha Beaulieu - Friendly Nurse
- Rachel G. Whittle - Realtor Sally
- Tracy Brotherton - News Reporter
- Olivia Luccardi - Lily Day
- Ben Chase - Nate Swanson
- Alice Barrett - Cathy Singer
- Kerry Cahill - Carol Alford
- Michael Hinson - Channel 2 Reporter
- Drew Scheid - Travis Hupp
- Patricia French - Minnie
- Rachael Thompson - Tina
- Becki Davis - Louis' Mom
- Luke Sexton - PV Fake Louis
- Merah Benoit - Leah Askey's Daughter
- Jenny Klein
- Jeremy Gold
- Liz Cole
- Chris Dickie
- Jason Blum
- Renée Zellweger
- Giona Ostinelli
- Sonya Belousova
Celia Weston hace el papel de Shirley Neumann.
Josh Duhamel interpreta a Joel Schwartz en la serie.
Judy Greer interpreta a Leah Askey en la serie.
Gideon Adlon interpreta a Mariah Day en la serie.
Sean Bridgers interpreta a Mark Hupp en la serie.
Suanne Spoke interpreta a Janet en la serie.
Mac Brandt interpreta a Detective Ryan McCarrick en la serie.
Katy Mixon interpreta a Betsy Faria en la serie.
Glenn Fleshler interpreta a Russ Faria en la serie.
Keith Morrison interpreta a Narrator (voice) en la serie.
Capítulo disponible en las siguientes plataformas:
