- Keith Morrison - Narrator (voice)
- Michael Carollo - Officer Divozzo
- Mike Harkins - O'Fallon Office Dave
- Barry Clifton - Jerry
- Randall D. Cunningham - Polygrapher
- Gralen Bryant Banks - Plastic Surgeon
- Ricky Catter - Gus
- Chad Governale - Courtroom Bailiff
- David Kors - Juror #3
- Dickson Obahor - Sean Walker
- William McGovern - Jim
- Morgan Roberts - Evan
- Ron Centanni - Russ' Family Member
- Didi Costine - Teenage Witch
- Jesse Scott Egan - Detective Merkel
- Anthony Michael Frederick - Firefighter
- Kyler Porche - Randy Gunderson
- Emily Topper - Young Pam Hupp
- Lara Grice - Cousin Mary
- Cindy Pol - Whitney
- Lorna Street Dopson - Zumba Instructor
- Kenny Alfonso - Bob Rivers
- Jackson Kelly - Big Shot Manager
- Cuyle Carvin - Btian Hilke
- Bill Martin Williams - Judge Ted House
- Suzette Lange - Prisoner
- Kurt McKinney - Judge Cunningham
- Jessie Terrebonne - O'Fallon County Operator
- Jay Pennington - Bradford Kessler
- Rob Steinberg - Michael J. Kruse
- John C. Klein - Bailiff
- Terese Aiello - 911 Operator
- Jordan V. Allen - CSI Tech
- Ann Mahoney - Tammy
- Jeff Robins - Juror #2
- Anne Speed - Bar Patron (uncredited)
- Adam David Thompson - Captain Mike Lang
- Billy Slaughter - Scott
- Alec Zais - Young Mark Hupp
- Catherine Carlen - Bonnie
- Lena Clark - Lisa
- Celia Weston - Shirley Neumann
- Douglas M. Griffin - Judge Ohmer
- Madeline Colombo - Bubbly Acolyte
- Ian Hoch - Cybercrimes Expert
- Sarah Stipe - Sarah Hupp
- Sarah Stipe - Sarah Hupp (uncredited)
- Susan Shalhoub Larkin - Luci
- Samantha Beaulieu - Friendly Nurse
- Rachel G. Whittle - Realtor Sally
- Tracy Brotherton - News Reporter
- Olivia Luccardi - Lily Day
- Ben Chase - Nate Swanson
- Alice Barrett - Cathy Singer
- Kerry Cahill - Carol Alford
- Michael Hinson - Channel 2 Reporter
- Drew Scheid - Travis Hupp
- Patricia French - Minnie
- Rachael Thompson - Tina
- Becki Davis - Louis' Mom
- Luke Sexton - PV Fake Louis
- Merah Benoit - Leah Askey's Daughter
- Jenny Klein
- Jeremy Gold
- Liz Cole
- Chris Dickie
- Jason Blum
- Renée Zellweger
- Giona Ostinelli
- Sonya Belousova
Celia Weston hace el papel de Shirley Neumann.
Josh Duhamel interpreta a Joel Schwartz en la serie.
Judy Greer interpreta a Leah Askey en la serie.
Gideon Adlon hace el papel de Mariah Day.
Sean Bridgers interpreta a Mark Hupp en la serie.
Suanne Spoke interpreta a Janet en la serie.
Mac Brandt interpreta a Detective Ryan McCarrick en la serie.
Katy Mixon hace el papel de Betsy Faria.
Glenn Fleshler hace el papel de Russ Faria.
Keith Morrison hace el papel de Narrator (voice).
Capítulo disponible en las siguientes plataformas:
