- Steve Eifert - Joey Buttafuoco
- Steve Eifert - Detective Verlin
- Lyle Menéndez - Self (archive footage)
- Erik Menéndez - Self (archive footage)
- Tweed Michael Manning - Phillip Taylor
- Cindy Copeland - Det. Charity Rose
- Dean Feldman - Det. Waggle
- Anthony Vance Pierce - Det. Murphy
- Amie Kieffer - Karen Coleman
- Stacy Nam - Dephne Wright
- Jay Heselschwerdt - Stepdad
- Jay Heselschwerdt - Delincino
- Bruce Cooper - Fred Brown
- Brett Driver - Kenneth Vaughn
- Tommy Kramer - Leroy Wentzel
- Richard Lamparter - Charles Schulz
- Alyx Libby - Candy Montgomery
- Ashton Faith Dixon - Shelly Harmon
- Jeni Lamm Bewer - Deborah Rudibaugh
- Felicia Andes - Letti Strait
- Tracey Reynolds - Lynn Boyd
- Caleb Wilkinson - Kevin Boyd Jr.
- Timothy - Mike George
- Rebecca Morris - Self - True Crime Author
- Joan Renner - Self - True Crime Author
- Dana Jay - Christopher 'Biggie Smalls' Wallace
- Shawn D. White - Danny Boy
- Jermaine Carter - Tupac
- Alvin Gray - Marion Hugh 'Suge' Knight
- James Arthur Williams - Robber
Capítulo disponible en las siguientes plataformas:
