- Gregg Henry - Officer Kean
- Jim Haynie - Officer Scott
- Barbara Tarbuck - School Counselor
- Scott Curtis - Cary Stayner (Age 11)
- Todd Eric Andrews - Cary Stayner (Age 18)
- Stephanie Walski - Cindy Stayner (Age 9)
- Hilary Morse - Cindy Stayner (Age 16)
- Sumer Park - Jody Stayner (Age 5)
- Shantell Stebbins - Jody Stayner (Age 12)
- Cassy Friel - Cory Stayner (Age 4)
- Marice Leeds - Cory Stayner (Age 11)
- Juney Ellis - Miss Rebecca
- Billy O'Sullivan - Victor (Age 7)
- Jason Presson - Deke
- Stephen Dorff - Pete
- Scott Reeves - Bruce
- Bryan Cranston - Officer Dickenson
- Dennis Fimple - Fred
- Vance Valencia - Selfides
- Shane McCabe - Fat Clerk
- Al Berry - Customer
- Brenda Hillhouse - Barbara
- Robina Suwol - Checker
- Kenneth Zavayna - Man
- Lyla Graham - Lady
- Nell Heller - Mrs. Alpha
- Anne Faulkner - Mrs. Ditschman
- Beth Grant - Mrs. Beta
- Lynnsey Ryan - Secretary
- Kenny McMurphy - Punk #1
- Raymond Cruz - Punk #2
- Karl Wiedergott - Punk #3
- Allison Mack - Nettie
- Ann Convery - Female Officer
- Amy O'Neill - Jodie
- Barry Corbin - Officer Warner
- Alan Fudge - Chief Johnson
- Jeremy McCollum - Kleekie
- Dan Kelpine - Court Officer
- Harold Pruett - Birch
- Jonathan Perpich - Officer Severeid
- William Frankfather - Judge Sabraw
- John Vickery - George McLure
- James Ingersoll - Joe Allen
- John DeMita - Dan Smith
- Billy Ray Sharkey - Sheriff Suggs
- Shannon Holt - Angela White
- Mark Tymchyshyn - Jim White
- Michael Chieffo - Don
- Whitney Rydbeck - Mr. Craft
- Natividad Vacío - Vicente
- Pamela McMyler - Rosanna
- Ron Tank - TV Journalist
- Andrew Amador - TV Reporter
- Robert Balderson - P.E. Teacher
- Mars Callahan - Victor (Age 14)
- Wendy Gordon - TV Newscaster
- Darcy DeMoss - Debbie
- Dave Adams - Cashier
- Annie O'Donnell - Official
- Tiiu Leek - Reporter #1
- Kim Maxwell - Reporter #3
- Kim C. Friese
- David Shire
Corin Nemec interpreta a Steven Stayner en la serie.
Cindy Pickett interpreta a Kay Stayner en la serie.
John Ashton hace el papel de Del Stayner.
Arliss Howard hace el papel de Kenneth Parnell.
Luke Edwards hace el papel de Steven Stayner (Age 7).
Pruitt Taylor Vince hace el papel de Irving Murphy.
Jacob Gelman hace el papel de Timmy White.
Ray Walston interpreta a Bob Augustine en la serie.
Peter Michael Goetz hace el papel de Pat Hallford.
Gregg Henry interpreta a Officer Kean en la serie.
Capítulo disponible en las siguientes plataformas:
