- Gregg Henry - Officer Kean
- Jim Haynie - Officer Scott
- Barbara Tarbuck - School Counselor
- Scott Curtis - Cary Stayner (Age 11)
- Todd Eric Andrews - Cary Stayner (Age 18)
- Stephanie Walski - Cindy Stayner (Age 9)
- Hilary Morse - Cindy Stayner (Age 16)
- Sumer Park - Jody Stayner (Age 5)
- Shantell Stebbins - Jody Stayner (Age 12)
- Cassy Friel - Cory Stayner (Age 4)
- Marice Leeds - Cory Stayner (Age 11)
- Juney Ellis - Miss Rebecca
- Billy O'Sullivan - Victor (Age 7)
- Jason Presson - Deke
- Stephen Dorff - Pete
- Scott Reeves - Bruce
- Bryan Cranston - Officer Dickenson
- Dennis Fimple - Fred
- Vance Valencia - Selfides
- Shane McCabe - Fat Clerk
- Al Berry - Customer
- Brenda Hillhouse - Barbara
- Robina Suwol - Checker
- Kenneth Zavayna - Man
- Lyla Graham - Lady
- Nell Heller - Mrs. Alpha
- Anne Faulkner - Mrs. Ditschman
- Beth Grant - Mrs. Beta
- Lynnsey Ryan - Secretary
- Kenny McMurphy - Punk #1
- Raymond Cruz - Punk #2
- Karl Wiedergott - Punk #3
- Allison Mack - Nettie
- Ann Convery - Female Officer
- Amy O'Neill - Jodie
- Barry Corbin - Officer Warner
- Alan Fudge - Chief Johnson
- Jeremy McCollum - Kleekie
- Dan Kelpine - Court Officer
- Harold Pruett - Birch
- Jonathan Perpich - Officer Severeid
- William Frankfather - Judge Sabraw
- John Vickery - George McLure
- James Ingersoll - Joe Allen
- John DeMita - Dan Smith
- Billy Ray Sharkey - Sheriff Suggs
- Shannon Holt - Angela White
- Mark Tymchyshyn - Jim White
- Michael Chieffo - Don
- Whitney Rydbeck - Mr. Craft
- Natividad Vacío - Vicente
- Pamela McMyler - Rosanna
- Ron Tank - TV Journalist
- Andrew Amador - TV Reporter
- Robert Balderson - P.E. Teacher
- Mars Callahan - Victor (Age 14)
- Wendy Gordon - TV Newscaster
- Darcy DeMoss - Debbie
- Dave Adams - Cashier
- Annie O'Donnell - Official
- Tiiu Leek - Reporter #1
- Kim Maxwell - Reporter #3
- Kim C. Friese
- David Shire
Corin Nemec interpreta a Steven Stayner en la serie.
Cindy Pickett interpreta a Kay Stayner en la serie.
John Ashton interpreta a Del Stayner en la serie.
Arliss Howard interpreta a Kenneth Parnell en la serie.
Luke Edwards interpreta a Steven Stayner (Age 7) en la serie.
Pruitt Taylor Vince hace el papel de Irving Murphy.
Jacob Gelman interpreta a Timmy White en la serie.
Ray Walston interpreta a Bob Augustine en la serie.
Peter Michael Goetz hace el papel de Pat Hallford.
Gregg Henry interpreta a Officer Kean en la serie.
Capítulo disponible en las siguientes plataformas:
