- Brian Kinney - Self - Judge
- Tom Savini - Self - Judge
- Jaime King - Self - Guest Judge
- R.L. Stine - Self - Guest Judge
- Rob Zombie - Self - Guest Judge
- Scout Taylor-Compton - Self - Guest Judge
- Shawnee Smith - Self - Guest Judge
- Rutina Wesley - Self - Guest Judge
- Chaske Spencer - Self - Guest Judge
- Sara Canning - Self - Guest Judge
- Danielle Harris - Self - Guest Judge
- Tony Todd - Self - Guest Judge
- Charlaine Harris - Self - Guest Judge
- Derek Mears - Self - Guest Judge
- Naomi Grossman - Self - Guest Judge
- Adi Shankar - Self - Guest Judge
- Francia Raísa - Self - Guest Judge
- Lew Temple - Self - Guest Judge
- Robin Atkin Downes - Self - Guest Judge
- Benjamin Papac - Self - Guest Judge
- Bex Taylor-Klaus - Self - Guest Judge
- Cassandra Peterson - Self - Guest Judge
- Sid Haig - Self - Guest Judge
- Carlson Young - Self - Guest Judge
- Gregory Plotkin - Self - Guest Judge
- Elizabeth Tulloch - Self - Guest Judge
- Shane West - Self - Guest Judge
- Robert Patrick - Self - Guest Judge
- Juliet Landau - Self - Guest Judge
- Bryan Fuller - Self - Guest Judge
- Fiona Dourif - Self - Guest Judge
- Sean Gunn - Self - Guest Judge
- John Kassir - Self - Guest Judge
- Mick Garris - Self - Guest Judge
- Gaten Matarazzo - Self - Guest Judge
- LeeAnna Vamp - Self - Guest Judge
- Colman Domingo - Self - Guest Judge
- Harley Quinn Smith - Self - Guest Judge
- Jackson Rathbone - Self - Guest Judge
- Caleb McLaughlin - Self - Guest Judge
- Jeremy Ray Taylor - Self - Guest Judge
- Guillermo Díaz - Self - Guest Judge
- Katie Sarife - Self - Guest Judge
- Jocelin Donahue - Self - Guest Judge
- Marisol Nichols - Self - Guest Judge
Shawnee Smith interpreta a Herself - Guest Judge en la serie.
Robert Patrick hace el papel de Himself - Guest Judge.
Jonathan Bennett hace el papel de Self - Host.
Shinmin Li interpreta a Self - Judge en la serie.
Aarti Sequeira hace el papel de Self - Judge.
Capítulo disponible en las siguientes plataformas:
