- Jordan Alexa Davis - Sarah Grohl
- Poorna Jagannathan - Elizabeth Vogel
- Tamara Hickey - Toby
- Hale Lytle - Matt McGrath
- Maria Elena Ramirez - Cara
- Ted Arcidi - Kingston
- Shawn Fitzgibbon - Detective Peterson
- William Xifaras - Father O'Leary
- Devon Diep - Reiko
- Cheryl McMahon - Mrs. Mandel
- Daryl Edwards - Judge French
- Therese Plaehn - Lita McGrath
- Myra Lucretia Taylor - Judge Rivera
- Aaron Andrade - Mr. Fuller
- Shannon Ashe - Christine
- Alfred Briere - Molloy
- Gene Dante - Ian
- Mai Delapa - Katie
- Frankie Francois - Sienna
- Rebecca Gibel - Wendy
- Collin Knight - Police Officer
- Ian Lyons - Burt Knox
- Melissa McMeekin - Roxanne
- Michele Proude - Court Clerk
- Carrie Ann Quinn - Kathleen
- Angela Hope Smith - Molloy's Counsel
- Patrick Fischler - Dan Rifkin
- Megan Byrne - Joan Rifkin
- Raymond Alongi - Park Ranger
- Michael Jibrin - Detective Freeman
- Sarah McLean - Female Officer
- Daniel Washington - Officer at Trailhead
- Sam Zephir - Officer #1
- Tom Mariano - Walpole Prison Guard
- Tobias Wilson - CPAC Trooper
- Audrey Wasilewski - Jeanine
- Kallie Tabor - Kirsten
- Lizzie Short - Andy's Mom
- Austin J. Ryan - Lacrosse Kid
- Marilyn Busch - Court Clerk
- Ken Cheeseman - Rod Renborg
- Rena Maliszewski - Karen Carlson
- Michael Tow - Reporter
- Michelle Violette - Paula Gianetto
- Jessi Case - Hope Connors
- Chelsea Hueter - Reporter
- Jake Swartz
- Morten Tyldum
- Adam Shulman
- Chris Evans
- Atli Örvarsson
Michelle Dockery hace el papel de Laurie Barber.
Jaeden Martell hace el papel de Jacob Barber.
Cherry Jones interpreta a Joanna Klein en la serie.
Pablo Schreiber interpreta a Neal Logiudice en la serie.
Betty Gabriel interpreta a Pam Duffy en la serie.
Sakina Jaffrey interpreta a Lynn Canavan en la serie.
Daniel Henshall interpreta a Leonard Patz en la serie.
Jordan Alexa Davis interpreta a Sarah Grohl en la serie.
Capítulo disponible en las siguientes plataformas:
