- Fiona Domenica - Patricia DeChristopher
- Baby Norman - Marie Huckins
- Spencer Mumford - Dennis Mitchell
- Steve Eifert - Forensic Inspector
- Amber Erwin - Donna Ferres
- Stefan Rollins - Calvin Cavey Jr.
- Ashton Leigh - Laura Craig
- Tyler Buckingham - Kevin Thorpe
- Alex Livinalli - Benjamin Silva
- Benjamin Keepers - Joseph Shelton
- Zach Lane - Norman Thomas
- Adam LeBow - Sheriff Lino Callegari
- Todd Anthony Manaigo - Sheriff Deputy
- Maureen Mountcastle - Laura's Mom
- Charles Green - Diner Owner
- Emily Tynan McDaniel - Connie Hilton
- Anthony Triceri - George Newman
- Patrick Lamont Jr. - Rickey Lynn Lewis
- Stephen Shane Martin - Det. Jason Waller
- Helen LeRoy - Melissa Anderson (as Helen Abell)
- Mark Costello - Will Hilton
- Douglas Dickerman - D.A. David Dobbs
- Misty Showalter - Misty Dubois (news reporter)
- Emily Topper - Tammy Crowe
- Bryan McClure - Wayne Legg
- Kristi Taylor - Susie Neiman
- Amber Sweet Sterner - Summer Hair
- Tahj Vaughans - Alphonso Lockett
- Sheldon Lance McCullough - Shawn Mathis
- Joshua Whichard - Matt Williamson
- Courtney Patterson - Heather Young
- Ethan McDowell - Gary Miller
- Jon Stafford - Brenton Walker
- Karen Ragan-George - Gail Walker
- Kate McManus - Danielle Stevens
- Matt Borlenghi - Det. Rich Rule (as Matthew Borlenghi)
- Schelle Purcell - Janet
- Jarrod Beck - Craig Monroe
- J. Benedict Larmore - David Eatherly
- Ariana Livingston - Lisa Holden
- Kellen Boyle - Josh Holden
- Meghan Colleen Moroney - Sue Ann Myers
- Kinsley Isla Dillon - Joy Holden
- Riley Madison Fuller - April Holden
- Jonathan Horne - Doug Anderson (as Jonathan Wesley Horne)
- Ariana Guerra - Rozina Anderson (as Ariana Aissa Guerra)
- Max Bickelhaup - Kip Patterson
- Lara Silva - Alicia Hernandez
- Ryan Davenport - John Kelley
- Steven Reddington - Cooper Larson
- Stephen David Calhoun - Commander Bill Stevens
- Keith Arthur Bolden - Lt. Carl Thompson
- Tony DeMil - Ron Meachum
- Sallye Hooks - Psychic Woman
- John Merical - Medical Examiner
- Emma Elle Roberts - Niky Mabry
- Celeste Marcone - Rebecca Smitley
- Jibre Hordges - Shawn Thompson
- Haley Leary - Michelle (as Haley Nicole Leary)
- Annabella Didion - Photographer (as Anna Didion)
- Rico Paris - Dane
- Rico Paris - James Keen
- Collin Alexander Brown - Sheriff Jim Sabin
- Ruan Martins - Det. Eamon Costello
- Danny Winn - Bill Grinnan
- TJ Jackson - Leeroy Rogers
- Bill Billions - Sgt. Pat Welsh
- Joshua Childs - Dale Pritchard
- Drew Starkey - Ethan Walton
Capítulo disponible en las siguientes plataformas: