- David Snyder - Kyle Strole
- Harry Holmes - Robbie Lemon
- Katie Franqueira - Claudette Ficik
- Conrad Sundqvist-Olmos - Jason
- Jesse Boone - Chris
- Natalie Bendheim - Suzanne
- Cyrus Hobbi - Martin Billings
- Josh Patton - Kenneth Smith
- Victoria Clare - Miranda Smith
- Isaiah Dell - Brady Smith
- Traci Elizabeth - Kathy
- Sara Spadacene - Shelby
- Colin Lawrence - Cat Eyes
- Kristen Springer - Sherri Justice
- Lawrence Moran - Det. Bert Hatfield (as Larry Moran)
- Robert Sisko - Det. Ray
- Taylor Mechlinski - FBI Agent Mark
- George Stumpf - Agent Mark Safarik
- Gregory DePetro - Prosecutor
- Lauren Elyse Buckley - Janet Walsh
- Tommy Schneiders - Scott Walsh
- Kendall Horn - Margie Farinacci
- Michael Mapél - Gregory Scott Hopkins
- Ian Watson - Victor Ciccozzi
- Alexander Catalano - Ron Ciccozzi
- Kevin Allen - Robert McGrail
- Beata Harju - Waitress
- Aaron Segal - Officer Andrew Gall
- Don Baldaramos - Detective Gall
- Eddie Aguirre - State Trooper de Maiolo
- Marty Dew - State Trooper Maddis
- Dwight Turner - Bridgewater Police Chief
- Paul Jacob Evans - Rev. Mosher
- Tony Cicchetti - Polygraph Operator
- Alberto David Mercado - Police Officer
- Kelly V. Dolan - Dana Laskowski
- Beckie Blosser - Emily Lauenborg
- Dawn Brodey - Shauna
- Kyle Devero - John
- Katie Freeman - Amanda Knott
- Hayden Michael Cruz Haas - Michael
- Jayden Hedden - Roy Jr.
- Steve Jacques - Mike
- Lauren Kelly - Susan
- Lauren Kelly - Susan Smith
- David Lansky - Cody
- Mark M. Souza - Stan
- Indi Star - Brandy
- William "Will" Daubert - Police Officer
- Steve Hosford - Cable Guy
- Terry Opp - Det. Gill
- Tom Wade - Det. Bram Hall
- Dennis Mattai - Polygraph Examiner
- Jack Aversano - Ray Kotomski
- Julian Brandon Bereny - Gavin
- Bryan Hanna - Roy Lovin
- Annie Boon Karstens - Phyllis Holcomb (as Annie Boon)
- Bob Rousseau - Robert Richard
- Dan Spector - Doctor
- Zack Sayenko - Det. Cleveland
- Nick Stellate - Det. Rose
- Keaton Shyler - Yelena Zakin
- Jillian Christi - Melissa Biegler
- Adam Daniel - John Cinko
- Gisla Stringer - Gloria
- Justen Overlander - Jimmy DeHollander
- Edwin Modlin II - Hunky Contractor
- Shantiel Alexis Vazquez - Military Wife
- Adam Vincent Wright - Det. Rick Archer
- Brett Keating - Morris Blankenbaker
- Angela Nordeng - Dee Ann Blankenbaker
- Brent Duffey - Reggie Chitwood
- Brent Duffey - Steven
- Eric Strong - Gabby Moore
- John Thomas Benson - Tuffy
- PJ Ortega - Curtis Lee
- Connor Linnerooth - Mike Moore
- Cort King - Vern Henderson
- Drew Thomas Allen - Pleas Green
- Zelika Chante - Loretta Scott
- Brey Chanadet - Todd
- Saphina Chanadet - Ryann
- Dustin Green - Steve
- Andrew Saunders - Warren
- G. Brian Benson - Dr. Jones
- Robert Gregory Browne - CSI Tech
- Claire Montgomery - Ruthie Ann Park
- Eric Feltes - Sam Park
- Sheldon Charron - Howard Martin (as John Charon)
- Melissa Schumacher - Linda Park-Martin
- Ian Davids - Richard McCraken
- Cameron Graham - Gary Dodge
- Spencer Paez - Santos
- April Moreau - Librarian
- Evan Clements - Actor
- Don Prosser - Chief Hicks
- Ronnie Kerr - Det. Dennis Fitzgerald
- David Benedict - Jay Orbin
- Amanda Elliott - Marjorie Orbin
- Lucas Royalty - Noah Orbin
- Phil Biondich - Robert Aime
- Bahara Golestani - Nora Bess
- Howard M. Lockie - Larry
- Thomas Pierre Maddox - Calvin Johnson
- Giovanni Capitello - Det. Barnes
- Courtney Dlugos - Det. Butcher
- Vicki Damante - CSI
- Michael Turner - CSI
- Robert Dominick Jones - Marshall Roosin
- Kevin Gance - Officer #2
- Nick Cabot Rodriguez - Junior Detective
- Jeremiah B. McQueen - SWAT Leader
- Rene Michelle Aranda - SWAT
- Rene Ruiz - Det. Tres
- David Hill - Bailiff
- Kim Rife - Diane Snellen
- Cameron Barnes - Danny Snellen
- Harvey B. Jackson - SWAT Officer
- Harvey B. Jackson - Holland MI Officer Shumaker
- Harvey B. Jackson - WA State Officer Gladden
- Tommy Kijas - Tim Crabtree
- Scotty Servis - Diane's Neighbor
- Matt Fling - Bill
- Tyrrell Cummings - Lee Greenup
- Michael Deni - David Dressman
- Rose Di Nardo - Stephanie Olson
- Damien Landini - Todd
- Abigail Arnold-Ochs - Janet Chandler
- Emma Barrow - Laurie Swank
- Alfredo Trueba - Arthur 'Carl' Paiva
- Dan Chlebanowski - Freddie Parker
- Michael J. Craven - James 'Bubba' Nelson
- Marco DelVecchio - Anthony Williams
- Brett Driver - Robert Lynch
- Tomas Johansson - Cold Case Detective #1
- Jason Maniscalco - Music Teacher
- Nikolay Moss - Investigator (as Nick Moss)
- Zander Stone - Guard #1
- Erick McAllister - Shawn Galloway
- Emily Rhoads - Other Woman
- Grant C. Hansen - Det. Jim Fairbanks
- Grant C. Hansen - Rob Dixon
- Shad Adair - Det. Don
- Rob Koebel - CSI Officer
- Justin Petry - Det. Tom Bell
- Ozy Reigns - Uniformed Officer
- Anthony Latona - Cellmate
- Alli George - Paige Birgfeld
- William Thomas Jones - Frank Birgfeld
- James Hal Hardy - Howard Beigler
- Leah Allers - Andrea Land
- Stephanie Arapian - Barbara Campbell
- Kim Marie Cooper - Lissah Norcross
- Lauren Gravitt - Jess
- Brendan Parry Kaufmann - Lester Jones
- Nick Manfredi - George Carolluzzo
- Mark Anthony Petrucelli - Joseph Carruth
- Zaydee Sanchez - Nubia
- Ed Gage - Howard's Guitarist
- Nicholas F. Philipp - Howard's Bass Player
- Brendan Connor - Deputy Sheriff Troy Mackie
- Ryan Patrick Dolan - Sheriff Hilkey
- Elizabeth Arends - Ann Jones
- Chase Drews - Art Simmers
- Iris Anthony - Geraldine
- Mel Chadwick - Henry
- Amanda Crown - Jenny Parks
- Michael Feig - Max Marlin
- Ryan Larson - Ron Nichols
- Scott Seven - Gene Pilcher (as Scott Erickson)
- Tomek Kosalka - Deputy #1
- Tyrone Van Tatenhove - Det. Wayne Sheston
- Jamon Holmes - Drug Dealer
- Kevyn Bashore - Diner
- Emily Rutan - Barbara Keim
- Kerr Lordygan - Joseph Keim
- William Castrogiovanni - Paul Stone
- Andrea Hickey - Dorothy Stone
- Terry Kaye - Lori, Barb's Sister
- Jimmy Avila - Officer James
- Richard Baxter - Officer Robert Baker
- Anthony Grant - Officer Lando
- Mark Krenik - Officer White
- Mindy Montavon - Spencer's Mom
- Drew Hale - Scott Bowers
- Ella Edwards - Mary Jayne Jones
- Holgie Forrester - Sue
- Concetta Potenza - Aunt Chippy
- Yoram Astrakhan
- Evelyn Hernandez
- Susan Turner
- Tammy Wood
- Angela Solis
- Brenden Clark
- Megan Morman
- AH2, LLC
- Jonathan Lastra
David Snyder hace el papel de Kyle Strole.
Harry Holmes interpreta a Robbie Lemon en la serie.
Katie Franqueira interpreta a Claudette Ficik en la serie.
Conrad Sundqvist-Olmos interpreta a Jason en la serie.
Jesse Boone interpreta a Chris en la serie.
Natalie Bendheim hace el papel de Suzanne.
Cyrus Hobbi interpreta a Martin Billings en la serie.
Josh Patton hace el papel de Kenneth Smith.
Victoria Clare interpreta a Miranda Smith en la serie.
Isaiah Dell interpreta a Brady Smith en la serie.
Capítulo disponible en las siguientes plataformas:
