- Matthew Cardarople - Creepy Steve
- Sam Richardson - Phil
- Steve Little - Bassnectar
- Ego Nwodim - Carolyn
- Randall Park - Real Steve
- Simon Rex - Eric
- Carol Swarbrick - Eric's Mom
- Steven Ogg - Jeff
- Mary Elizabeth Ellis - Mia
- Anna Faris - Whitney
- Rebecca Stoughton - Mermaid
- Echo Kellum - Derrick
- Cameron Britton - John
- Jon Gries - Denver
- David Banks - Police Officer
- Ernest Harden Jr. - Detective Bowlin
- Sufe Bradshaw - Judge
- Betsy Sodaro - The Vigilante
- Elizabeth De Razzo - Monica
- Heather Wynters - Maxine
- Jake Johnson - Bunny-Hanting Man
- Lauren Lapkus - Absolute Sociopath
- Juliette Lewis - Kim
- Buddy Daniels Friedman - Potato Head
- Whit Spurgeon - Potato Head
- Bobby Lee - Officer Mendoza
- Daphnique Springs - Officer Nina
- Michael Hitchcock - Bail Bondsman Tim
- Scott MacArthur - Lawyer Mike
Capítulo disponible en las siguientes plataformas:
